AT&T and T-Mobile Merger – It’s a Sprint to the Finish…

So AT&T has bought T-Mobile…what a surprise.  Did anyone believe something like this wasn’t bound to happen, eventually?  Did anyone ever think that it wouldn’t be AT&T and Verizon in the end, just like the US and Soviets during the Cold War? 

Well, hold your virtual horses for now because the deal is still pending regulators consent, but let’s pretend  just for a moment.  Let’s pretend that the merger is approved and AT&T absords T-Mobile USA.  What does it mean to the others?

The Consumers – right off the bat, I think consumers will prosper over this merger.  The merger gives AT&T more resources; for example, they can now utilize T-Mobiles infrastructure.  More resources, mean more leverage, which means lower costs in the end.  AT&T’s ability to lower costs, will likely spark competition and force competitors, like Verizon, to lower their costs.    Many might argue the consumer will lose here because there are fewer choices and greater potential for a monopoly.  Let me remind you a monopoly means one; even if we are left with Verizon and AT&T, it’s not a monopoly.  You might have less choice, but honestly, right now, I’d rather have 2 good choices, than 1 great choice, a good choice and a few sub-par choices.  In addition, for those worried AT&T and Verizon would collectively dabble in unfair business practices under Anti-Trust laws, do you really think these 2 companies could ever play nice together?

The competitors – Sprint is in trouble.  Sprint had hoped to merge with T-Mobile, but that is obviously not going to happen with this proposed AT&T merger.  Now Sprint is going to be running for its life with little room to breath.  They have little leverage to compete with the competitor’s price points and honestly, they don’t have the products either.  My suggestion here is for them to work out a deal with Verizon (like they would actually ask for my suggestion…).  They share the same CDMA technology, so it seems like a match made in heaven.  Worried a Verizon/Sprint merger would never be approved, you say?  Well, if the regulators approve the AT&T/T-Mobile merger, they are kind of setting a precedent to approve a Verizon/Sprint merger. 

Of course, there is still much to go before we see a completion to any official merger.  The merger must now be approved by the government, so it will be interesting how all of this plays out in the coming weeks.

Advertisements

The Thunderbolt has arrived – will lightning only strike once for extending your unlimited data plan beyond this Summer?

 

Today marks the release of the much-anticipated HTC Thunderbolt from Verizon.  So why was the Thunderbolt such an anticipated device?  Besides having a cool name, the reason is because it is the first 4G (or LTE…however you prefer to call the next generation network) phone on the Verizon network.  While it is the first phone on 4G, many are asking should I go out and buy one, or a more common question asked specifically to me is, will I go out and buy one? 

If you would have asked me a couple of months ago, I would have said, no, I’m waiting, simply because there are a bunch of other 4G phones on the horizon, and I am also curious what the iPhone 5 will have in store (despite not likely being on Verizon until next year..imo).  Of course, that is if you asked me a few months (even weeks) ago.  I have since started to think (I do this every so often) and it hit me how well Verizon has played its hand these past few months…that’s assuming my assumptions here are accurate. 

Let’s look at some of the facts so far:

  • Verizon just released the most popular smartphone ever on their 3G network, the iPhone, locking people into a contract for at least the next year (likely 2 yrs).
  • Verizon has stated that the unlimited data plans will be going away, likely sometime this Summer.
  • Your rate is usually locked in, at least until the end of your plan term, or you make changes to your services.

If Verizon starts to not offer unlimited data plans beginning this Summer, if you are already locked into the unlimited plan, you will likely be grandfathered in and able to stick with unlimited, at least until your contract is up for renewal or until you make a service change (there is a gray area here, so these are the assumptions).  But, if you are one of the people who makes the change from 3G to 4G after the unlimited is phased out, you will likely be in the position where you have to take one of the new “limited” data plans. 

So while waiting for the other phones could be a good thing, it could also work against you because making the service change from 3G to 4G, later this year, could force your hand in forfeiting your unlimited plan for one of the new limited data plans (depending when Verizon makes the change from unlimited to limited only plans). 

Also, all the people who signed up and got an iPhone are trapped in the 3G world until their contract expires; unless, they go out and buy a new 4G phone at full cost.  By the time the iPhone users are up for renewal, I assume most of the new phones will be on the 4G network, so even if you are grandfathered on the 3G network, you are going to eventually have to make the change to 4G, hence likely going to lose the ability to stay on the old unlimited plan. 

The best case scenario than is to be one of the first in on the 4G network before anything is changed.  Once on the 4G plan, as long as you stay with 4G and don’t swap out onto a different data plan (ie.  Blackberry Corporate vs. Smartphone), you should be grandfathered into the plan.  Even if your contract expires, I wonder if you would still have the ability to keep the unlimited…hmm?   

Remember, a lot is assumed here based on what has transpired for me in the past with Verizon.  I don’t work for Verizon, nor has anyone from Verizon confirmed any of these assumptions to me.  I am clearly speculating, based on what I have seen from being a Verizon customer the past 10+ years.  I can tell you I ran into a similar situation with the mobile hotspot/tethering service and it wasn’t until I let my Blackberry go and hooked up my Droid that they changed my tethering plan from the, no longer offered, $15/unlimited, to the new $20/2G plan.  If I would have kept the Blackberry, I would have continued to enjoy the $15/unlimited tether option, since I was grandfathered into that service option.  

For all we know, Verizon could just make everyone change their data plans; regardless of when your contract expires, or phase people out based on some internal algorithm.  The data plans are just considered an added service, taken on a month to month basis, so they likely have these options without going against your contract.  On the other hand, they could  just grandfather all loyal customers into unlimited, although this is very unlikely – probably more likely they just keep the unlimited plans and just raise the price.   What I do know, is I would rather take my chances now and move to a 4G unlimited plan with the chance of being grandfathered in, rather than take that chance later, knowing they will more than likely take away my unlimited once I change over. 

It might be time to get out the lighting rod, and get into some of this thunder, before it’s too late!   Thunder….Thunder…Thunderbolt…Hoooo!  (yes, I had to say it…I grew up in the 80s, I couldn’t let it go…snarf…snarf..snarf…okay, I’m done)

iPad 2 is Bleeding Conspiracy!

The iPad 2 has been out for less than a week now and it seems a potentially major problem has been discovered.  Many people are reporting that their iPad is experiencing “screen bleed”.   I’m not going to go into the details of screen bleed.  If you are interested, please check out this link to Gizmodo – they do a great job explaining and showing you the actual problem – http://gizmodo.com/#!5781452/the-ipad-2-is-bleeding.

The point of this post is my new conspiracy theory, which plays nicely into my previous post, where I believe an iPad 2.5 will be released this September.  If you note, one of the things I predicted that would be part of the September model was…wait for it…a new retina display!  Well, look at what we already have here with the iPad 2 – a bad display!  Wonder how widespread this issue is?  Was it just a bad batch?  Is the screen incompatible with the new chip?  Probably a long shot, but a nice transition in for Apple to say, well, we do have a minor screen problem and to mitigate the risk of it continuing to happen in the future, we have upgraded to a better improved screen! 

So what do you think now – iPad 2.5, coming this Fall, to an Apple store near you?

iPad 2 – What’s the Plan?

 Verizon, AT&T and Apple are all set to start selling iPad 2 devices tomorrow, beginning at 5pm EST. 

If you were considering getting a Verizon ready iPad, here are the plans that will be offered:

  • 1GB per month – $20
  • 3GB per month – $35
  • 5GB per month – $50
  • 10GB per month – $80

If anyone has a data plan on their smartphone and utilizes the hotspot feature for an extra $20 a month, you might start reading between the lines on these plans.  For $20 a month, I can use my smartphone as a mobile hotspot and have my iPad hooked up to the Internet via the phone.  While it drains the battery a bit, it is a lot cheaper at $20/2GB, then the plans above.  It makes me wonder what Verizon has in store for the mobile hotspot plans.  We already know the unlimited plans on the phones are going away…I have a feeling the $20/2GB hotspot/tether plans will change in the near future too, to look more like the plans above. 

If you are an AT&T user, the plans offered, will look these below:

  • $14.99/250 MB per month
  • $25/2GB per month

Overage on the plans varies based on the carrier and the specific plan.  See carrier for details.

Your smartphone battery draining the life out of you?

Did you just buy one of the latest smartphones, only to find it consumes your battery quicker than the next Charlie Sheen story can be published on a major news site? Wondering why such a sophisticated device can run at ancient capacity levels? The problem actually isn’t capacity, the problem is demand for that capacity. Since the devices are becoming much more powerful, they are requiring more power! The recently announced Thunderbolt that will run on Verizon’s 4G network has, as many know, been delayed and the rumor is the device has battery issues. More speed, usually means faster processing, which equates to more required juice.

If you find yourself charging your phone every 4 hrs, and are not willing to upgrade to a larger capacity battery, here are some quick hits that should improve your battery levels:

  • Turn off your location services – this includes Google, Verizon (or whoever your provider is), and GPS. This will impact your instant weather and any cool features that require these services to know your location, but how often do you really use them, and you can always turn them back on when you do.
  • Lower the brightness of your screen and don’t use auto bright. Your display is your worst enemy when it comes to consuming the battery. Keep it at a minimum.
  • Watch out for programs that auto sync or pull information regularly. Getting your tweets every 5 minutes; perhaps your e-mail every 10 minutes? Every time your phone goes out to get this info, it costs you battery power. If you only check this info every hour, have those services only poll every hour. You can usually poll on-demand, so if you happen to check before the next scheduled poll, you have options available to you.
  • Turn off your WiFi – if you aren’t using it, turn it off. Yes, you will have to remember to turn it back on when you are home or wherever you use WiFi, assuming you do, but WiFi “always on” draws a lot of power because the phone is constantly looking for connections. There are also programs out there that will allow you to better manage your WiFi, if you are adamantly against turning it off.
  • Bluetooth – see WiFi above – just insert “Bluetooth”; wherever, you see “WiFi”.

While this is not an all-inclusive list and there are surely other ways to preserve your battery, this should provide a good place to start.

Things your Parents didn’t tell you – Netbook or Tablet??

Are you like one of the many people I have spoken to recently, trying to decide what is the right device for you?  Do you need a very mobile device, but are not sure if you should go with the traditional Netbook or get caught up in the tablet hype?  Well, I can tell you first hand, I own both types of devices and there is a time and place for each of them.  What I hope to accomplish here, is provide a little bit more insight on the pros and cons for each.

Netbook

What is it?   A netbook is a stripped down laptop that runs the same type of  operating system, your typical desktop or laptop runs.  Some netbooks these days are borderline laptops and vice versa, but generally a netbook sports a screen size between 10-13 inches, does not have any CD/DVD Drives and is less powerful, than your average laptop.  Netbooks are designed to provide portability and efficiency, hence the small screen sizes and less impressive specs.  They were originally targeted at people looking for a more economical  system that would allow them to surf  the web, check e-mail and perform basic pc tasks (ie.  MS Office).   Today, some netbooks are a bit more powerful, like the one I am typing on right now.  Mine houses a faster processor and graphic card, but comes at a price, specifically, greater cost and  6 fewer hours of battery power than your average netbook.  It’s all really personal preference.  The bottom line is a netbook is good for anything that will require you to type a lot and  jump between applications.  If you are like me and want to work remotely every now and then and need to link into another desktop or device, a netbook would provide the perfect blend of functionality and portability.  If you are a blogger, like some others you might know, and will be doing a lot of typing, a netbook would also meet these requirements. 

Tablet

What is it?  It’s an iPad…okay, just kidding, obviously there are more tablets out there than just the iPad.  A tablet is a flat device with a touch screen that allows you to do various tasks.  It runs a mobile operating system, like iOS, Android, or WebOS.  What are these mobile OS I speak of?  Do you have a smartphone?  If so, you have a mobile OS on your phone.  As you already know, one of the advantages of how your phone operates is instant gratification.  Another words, as soon as you turn the device on, it is ready to serve you.  Even when you completely reboot the device, it comes back to life, ready to roll, fairly quickly….of course, unless you have  Blackberry…sorry RIM, but 11 minutes to reboot my Blackberry Storm 2 was never a fun experience (at least it was consistently always 11 minutes).   This leads me to one major advantages of a tablet – it’s always ready to go.  There are no long boot times.  If you are looking for a very portable device, that you can turn on and off without delay, the tablet could be for you.  If you have a smartphone, and love it, but find the screen too small, then the tablet is for you.  If you want that device you can sit on the couch and surf the web, the tablet is for you.  The tablet provides quick, on demand portability.  What it won’t provide is the ability to multi-task efficiently between applications or type well (although the tablet is making strides here with 3rd party products). 

Still confused on what this all means?  Here is the quick and dirty rundown: 

Netbook

Pros

  • Fully functional OS – true multitasking and integration with other devices
  • Easier to type (for the most part)

Cons

  • Slower start-u whether full boot-up or just being “woken”
  • Harder to manuever, while in transit – opening and closing screen and typing..there’s a reason they are called laptops (and physically, other than size, a netbook is inherently a laptop)

Who would benefit most – users looking to work remotely, bloggers, students, people who want a more portable device to their laptop, economical alternative to a laptop or desktop replacement

Tablets

Pros

  • “Always ready” – little wait to boot up and ready to serve when needed
  • Easier to use on the go – no keyboard and completely flat
  • Inherits same full functionality a desktop would have since it uses same OS

Cons

  • Multi-tasking between apps is very challenging
  • No keyboard built-in other than touch screen
  • functionality is limited since it runs on a mobile OS and not the same OS a full-blown desktop would run on

Who would benefit most – couch surfers (Internet), users who are looking for a personal assistant (portfolio) replacement, students (as a supplement to a netbook), workers in the field that normally carry client info (ie. sales, real estate, Dr,  etc.), e-readers who want the best of all the e-reading device world.

iPad is less “Spec”-tacular, but should remain more popular

As I have harped upon in my previous posts, the iPad 2 enhancements were predictable and anything but a technological breakthrough.  The mother of all Android tablets on the other hand, which at this moment is the Moto Xoom, has some impressive specs and features, which many are saying could give the iPad a run for its money.  While I agree, I would like to provide some reasons I believe the iPad will remain the leader in the tablet market.

  • Let’s start with cost.  What does the new iPad 2 really mean to the marketplace?  It means there will be plenty of original iPads to snatch up at a great value, whether it be by purchasing a new one discounted to clear out of inventory, or a used one on Ebay, Craigslists, etc.  The bottom line is the original iPad is still a cool device, far from being outdated and well worth the discounted price tag.  People who couldn’t afford the entry-level $500 price tag  to play with the next best innovative device, can now flock to get them at much more affordable price.   More iPads in the marketplace, means more buzz and demand for the devices, all while price points diminish.  It’s like the perfect storm!  (Certainly, the law of supply and demand states demand will cause prices to rise, but remember, they can only rise so high for the first generation iPad, with iPad 2 out there. )

 

  • The iPad might not look as techy as the Android, but that can actually be a good thing.  iOS can be viewed as “boring”, but boring can equate to simple, and when dealing with a technical device,  most people like simple.  Not to mention, the device is still a great looking experience!

 

  • Apple is already trusted and mainstream.  Ever play the game where I say a word and you have to immediately say what comes to mind?  Let’s play:
    • Phone…
    • Tablet…

             Did they both happen to start with “i”.

  • Verizon is promoting Apple products now and is not an Android exclusive shop (yes, there is also Blackberry, but when is the last time you happen to see a Verizon Blackberry commercial).  Verizon is a big player in the mobile world and advertising Apple along side Android, definitely helps Apple…at least a lot more than when they weren’t promoting Apple. 

 

Can others compete with the iPad – surely, as I have noted in previous posts.  I just don’t see it coming as soon as many might think.

Bold Predictions!

I would like to start off the week by presenting some of my predictions (pure speculation – no solid facts to back these folks) for the upcoming year, with regards to some key mobile devices:

iPad 2.5 – I see in my crystal ball, another incremental update around September of this year.  Included with the iPad Premium (aka 2.5) line will be increased memory options (say a 32, 80, and 128 gig’er), retina display, and possibly a USB port! 

iPhone 5 – thinner and larger.  Larger screens seem to be the cool kids of smartphones these days, so I expect a 4.0 inch screen, off-set by an overall thinner device.  I expect the iPhone 5 to be released by the end of this summer, but Verizon customers shouldn’t hold their breath for it, until at least 6 months after initial release. 

iPhone 4G – not sure when and I am pretty sure it won’t be the next iPhone 5 coming this summer, but it will happen and it will be Verizon to bring it first, to a 4G network close to you.  (If I had to predict a date – late next year, 2012)

Window Tablets – I have a netbook and I have an iPad.  The netbook still allows true multi-tasking, easy integration with other PCs and the file systems.  The iPad provides instant gratification, as it takes no time to boot up and is ready for me immediately – it lacks in the areas I mentioned the netbook was good.  If Microsoft can provide an innovative experience with their Windows tablet, they might have a shot into the market.  The only problem is they are now saying their devices won’t be out until 2012, which only allows the competition more time to give Microsoft a reason to put their tablets on clearance, shortly after their release. 

Blackberry Playbook – this is a tough one to call.  I personally don’t like it much, but I have not played with one,  so again only going with what I read and see online.  I read you can integrate with your BES account, but only if you have a Blackberry phone.  That’s annoying in my opinion.  Blackberry has always relied on the business and enterprise users and I see a lot of businesses working with the iPad right now.  Like Microsoft, the delay to market might have hurt Blackberry’s chances here. 

Android Tablets – from what I see, if you take away the cost, the Moto Xoom has a good chance to take on the iPad.  The problem is the cost.  I am not sure that many people are ready to pay that much for a tablet, especially when the mainstream product, the iPad, can be had for less.  Gadget geeks and highly intelligent tech people might disagree, but that is not the complete make-up of all the consumers these devices should be targeting, if you want to make an impact.  Speaking of the gadget geeks, right now, that’s where i see the Android market staying because….

The iPad will win the tablet battle this year and keep its lead in the tablet market.  Why you ask?  Look for my reasons, later today.

The Future of Mobility

The announcement of the iPad 2 kindled (not the Amazon one) something inside of me this week.  I have provided a few angles on the new iPad, but wanted to close out the week looking at how I view the future of the mobile market. 

Undoubtably, mobile devices have finally taken off and are becoming more mainstream.  What was once seen as a techy item, is being used by professors, business people, mothers, students, and even Grandma and Grandpa Joe. 

The evolution of the smartphone has taken a turn.  What was once a push for smaller is better has turned to a balance between functionality and size.  With the smartphone becoming more functional, allowing users to surf the web and watch movies etc, consumers started seeing the benefit to larger screens.   What we are seeing now is the advent of larger screen smartphones and tablets to satisfy the increased functionality.  A new strike between functionality and convenience.  

So what does the longer term future look like for smartphones and tablets.  Who will be the front-runner, and what will they need to do to stay on top.  Obviously, Apple is seen as the leader at this time, but can Android or even Blackberry catch up?  Keep in mind, when I present these questions, I am writing with regards to the US market.  The addition of the International markets would change everything and add some more players. 

Right now, I see the major US players in the mobile space as:

  • Apple
  • Google – Android
  • Blackberry
  • Microsoft

What do each of these players have to do, in order to stay competitive?  Well, for starters they need to continue to innovate and improve on their products, while keeping their costs down.  This is a given for all of the players above. 

Let’s look at the specifics for each player:

Apple

  • They need to open up.  They are too stuck on a proprietary mindset and this already got them in trouble in the 80s.  Add a USB port to the iPad, allow an SD port, let me see my files and folders and transfer stuff without using iTunes.
  • More product lines – the one reason the Android devices have better specs is because Apple only provides product upgrades once a year.  You want the next best iPhone, it could take 1-2 years.  With the Android, HTC is coming out with one phone, while Motorola is already working on the next best thing.  This keeps the product line fresh. 
  • Realize Google is for real.  I know no one has been able to touch the iPod, but Google has a good chance to make a run at Apple with phones and tablets.  According to Steve Jobs at the iPad 2 unveiling, iPad is 90% of the market today, but keep approaching it from a standpoint that no one can beat you and someone will…especially when it’s Google in the rearview mirror.

Google

  • Push to become more mainstream and less techy.  Nothing wrong with techy people, I could be considered one of them, but a phone branded as “techy” for some is an automatic classification of “scary” for others.   Start marketing campaigns branding your products towards less tech oriented market segments.
  • Improve your security model.  This might be a difficult one since Google’s model relies on openness.  Education might be the best practice here or having a security program pre-installed might help reduce the risk. 
  • Lower your price points of your higher end products.  The Motorola Xoom was deemed the iPad killer.  I must admit, it looks pretty nice, but the price point is too high.  $600+ and I have to sign a contract with Verizon?  Apparently, a cheaper model in the $500 range will be released at Sam’s Club with only Wi-Fi, but when there are cheaper iPad options, who do you think will get the majority of the market?  Android is in the position where it need to impress and get itself out there, not price itself out of the market.  Think of Vizio TVs – they were high quality and in a lot of cases a better product, but the main way they got out there in the market and proved themselves was on price. 

Blackberry

  • Stick with what you are good at and appease your main market.  Blackberry is still alive because of the security and their seamless Enterprise integration.  Businesses that require tight controls, especially government related, will turn to the Blackberry.  For Apple and Android, they are out to appease the average consumer right now with new and innovative things.  Their models aren’t tied around security and in some cases, like I mentioned with the Android,  harbor less security.  For Blackberry, they are seen as lacking in innovation, but sometimes boring means stability and security. 
  • Don’t lose complete sight of innovation. 

Microsoft

I only mention them because I am sure they will make some kind of run in the mobile space, but they have a lot of catching up to do.  So did Apple in the 90s…

What about tablets?  Are they the future or a fad?  I think they can be the future, but they can fizzle out if not marketed properly.  The main way to keep the tablet heartbeat alive is to get it into the workforce; Seamless integration within the Enterprise.   This is key!

I have had my iPad for two weeks now and I love it.  I am also starting to realize everything I do on it, I can do somewhere else and better.  For example, it acts as an e-reader, but so does my Kindle and the books on my bookshelf.  It plays Netflixs, but so does my 65 inch TV.   It acts as a computer, but my netbook definitely is my device of choice when working or writing.  Don’t get me wrong, I love my iPad, but others might come to realize, they don’t really need it. 

If the tablet can get itself into the Enterprise workforce, it can prove that it is more than just a cool gadget.  I think this is achievable and already in the works in many places.  During the iPad 2 announcement, there were many examples of different professions using the iPad.  And now with the camera, the options are even greater.  Remember when we use to watch sci-fi shows with workers communicating with each other via tablets – can you say Facetime on the iPad!  The industry must continue to come up with more practical uses of tablets; otherwise, people are going to realize their smartphone does enough for them on the go.  If I had to bet on tablets continuing to be a future game changer, I would probably take the bet.

The Duel of Fates – iPhone vs. Android

photo above retrieved from http://www.wallpaper4me.com 

 

The iPhone on Verizon was supposed to be an easy choice – right?  I remember getting my first Blackberry and trading in my Palm Treo.  It was sad to give up the Treo, but the Blackberry allowed me to access my corporate e-mail.  Then came the Blackberry Curve – a solid communication device, but lacking in multimedia.  The answer to my multimedia issue was the Blackberry Storm 2 and yes, it was a bad answer.  So I waited and waited, hoping the obvious answer would be released to the Verizon Gods.  I prayed each night that someone would find a mis-print or spelling error in the AT&T exclusive deal with Apple…but it didn’t happen.  I counted down the days for that deal to expire, and waited patiently for Verizon to announce the iPhone would come to their network.  Then something unexpected happened – the Red Eye appeared.  

It was a cold Fall night, while watching primetime TV and surfing my netbook.  It called to me on the television, like it was my guardian angel (or a demented demon – however you want to look at it).  It’s voice was clear, music to my ears…it said…Droooid.   It was at that moment, I knew Google had thrown a wrench in my plans with their Android operating system!  

The Motorola Droid put Android on the map and many more device would follow, including the Droid X and the HTC Incredible.  So what did this mean now for my match made in heaven with the iPhone, if and when it came to Verizon?  Well, for me, it was over.  The Droid was now my phone of choice.  I left my Blackberry, and kicked the iPhone idea to the curb.  It was a triangle love story in the making.  All along I had planned on running off with my wife’s arch rival in High School, who was currently overseas, but instead I cheated on both, and ran off with the new girl in town!

I believe many people are having the same dilemma these days.  No, not with their wives and girlfriends (see some other blogs for that topic…), but when it comes to the their next smartphone.  Is the Android or the iPhone the better phone?  Unfortunately, there is no easy answer.  Which phone is better, depends on what you are looking for in your next smartphone.    So while I cannot offer anything more than an opinion on which I like better for myself, I can try to go over some general difference, I noticed between the iOS and Android operating systems. 

I bring up the operating systems because that is the heart and soul of these devices’ functionality and really the heart of the problem at hand.  I want to strip away the hardware and additional software packs some manufacturers (mainly on the Android phones) include on these devices because this is about Apple vs. Android.  Not HTC Incredible vs. Motorola Droid X.  Figure out you want a Droid first, before you worry about which one.

So enough rambling;  Below I put together a quick list of what I perceive as the main differences between the devices:

Android

  • Plays well with other systems – – less restrictive 
  • Flexible customization and open file access, but can be overwhelming
  • Ability to add more memory in the form of an SD card
  • Fewer Apps, but it seems to have more free apps than Apple
  • Security can be an issue out of the box
  • More choices of hardware across various manufacturers (ie.  Incredible, Droid X, Moto Droid etc.)
  • Cutting edge specs
  • Integrates great with Google products

Apple iOS

  • More restrictive customization and file access – “proprietary” model
  • Simple interface – user-friendly
  • Mature app market, but at a price
  • Tighter security, but not as tight as the Blackberry
  • Less choice (you have the iPhone – yes, different generations, but still one device made by one manufacturer)
  • Maturer Product
  • Integrates well with Mac OS and iTunes
  • I would bet most iPhone users will have a more expensive experience in the end when accounting for the price of the phone and apps

Playing with both operating systems, my first impression with Android was flexibility.  The Android provides a lot of ways you can customize your user experience.  This includes setting up your home screen to categorize your icons, or having items like widgets,  streaming up to the minute information.  The wallpaper selection is also incredible, with the option to have “live” animated wallpaper.  When you plug your Android into a PC, it can automatically be used as a mounted Hard drive, allowing  access to all files.  

The Android Marketplace is growing everyday, with so many choices available to you, but still not nearly as many choices as I found with the Apple App store.  The one bright spot over Apple was there seemed to be more free applications in the Android Marketplace. 

With flexibility, openness and more freebies comes a cost, which is security.  Since Android is open source and less restrictive, there are more opportunities for exploits and hacks.  Just recently, there were a group of applications found in the Android Marketplace that had malicious code within them.  These apps in some cases had over 50,000 downloads at the time!  You would be hard pressed to find something like this in the Apple App store, not that it would be impossible.  

The Android has a distribution model in place that forges competition, which might explain why every new Android phone that comes out has a bit more to offer than the last.  The iPhone is the only Apple phone around at this time.  If you want the next generation device, you need to wait, usually at least a year, for Apple to upgrade.  With Android, companies like HTC, Motorola and LG to name a few are all competing with each other to deliver the next best device.  For some this might be frustrating because you feel outdated quicker, but it provides healthy competition amongst Android providers. 

Working with the Apple iOS device, I found that it was a much easier user experience.  You had your home screens, which you could navigate left and right.  The number of apps you had would dictate the number of screens.  While you could move your app icons around and create folders, there was no option for widgets or shortcuts.  In addition, you could change your wallpaper, but only to static photos. 

Working with files and programs was definitely more restrictive on the iOS.  I could not figure out a way (and there might not be a way) to get to my folders or file system.  In order to look at a word doc, play a song, or view a photo, I had to go through iTunes or open the file using a cloud based solution.  Unlike the Android, the device did not have the option to mount as a hard drive (although I do see there are 3rd party programs that will let you do this).  

Since Apple’s iOS is more restrictive, it has tighter security wrapped around it, but don’t be confused, it is not as tight as the Blackberry. 

While Apple is the only show in town for the iPhone, offering one line of phones, it is a more mature line.  Android has more choices, but many are new lines of phones that come at a risk, with little performance history.  For example, when the Incredible was first released, there were battery issues.  That’s not to say Apple hasn’t had its share of issues – just ask the iPhone 4 users with the mysterious antenna problems.  I believe some are deeming it “Antennagate”.   

Of course either of these products are going to integrate with its other product lines.  For the Android, I found Google Maps and Voice to work seamlessly.  Apple has a lot of apps that integrate well with their Mac Desktop counterpart, although in many cases you have to pay twice for the app (mobile and desktop version). 

In the end, it really depends on your preference and what works best for you.  If you are the techy type and/or you like the freedom to customize your device and are willing to take some steps to better lockdown your phone, you would do well with the Android.  If you are looking for a simpler, user-friendly experience and don’t want to do much customization out of the box, then the iPhone might be for you.  Of course, if you are looking purely for a message/communication device (imagine looking for just that in a smartphone!) that offers top-notch security and don’t care about innovative features, stick with the Blackberry.   

I leave you with some summary words that fit each device:

Android

  • Flexible
  • Expandable
  • Cutting Edge
  • Vulnerable
  • Value

Apple

  • User-Friendly
  • Mature
  • Proprietary
  • Innovative
  • Proven

Below is a comic I caught on some other blogs.  The author of the comic is C-Section Comics.  I thought this was hilarious and wanted to share with everyone else, since it is relevant to the topic at hand.  You can find other works by this author on their website, www.csectioncomics.com.